top of page

Court Dismisses Musk's Lawsuit Against Bright Data in Landmark Data Scraping Case

A California federal court, presided over by Judge William Alsup, has dismissed a lawsuit brought by Elon Musk's X Corporation against the Israeli firm Bright Data. The lawsuit, stemming from allegations of data scraping practices, saw X accusing Bright Data of unlawfully extracting data from its platform and selling it in violation of X's terms of service and copyright regulations.

Judge Alsup's ruling emphasized that X's primary concern appeared to be monetary compensation for the extracted data rather than safeguarding user privacy. He underscored that while X had anti-scraping measures in place, it seemed willing to permit data extraction as long as remuneration was secured. This dismissal echoes a legal precedent set in a 2022 case involving LinkedIn, reinforcing the notion that scraping publicly accessible online data, though possibly against a platform's terms of service, does not inherently breach legal boundaries or copyright laws.

Bright Data, for its part, contended that public online information belongs to everyone and that attempts to restrict access are bound to fail. The ruling aligns with previous litigation, notably Meta's (formerly Facebook) unsuccessful lawsuit against Bright Data over similar data scraping allegations. This verdict holds broader implications for the ongoing discourse surrounding data privacy, public access to information, and the utilization of such data for both commercial and AI-driven endeavors.

2 views0 comments

Recent Posts

See All


bottom of page